The boxing world is buzzing with the possibility of a legendary rematch, but not everyone is convinced it's a good idea. James Toney, a boxing legend himself, has some strong opinions on Floyd Mayweather's potential return to the ring against Manny Pacquiao.
A Rematch Years in the Making:
The narrative begins in 2015 when Mayweather and Pacquiao finally faced off, with Mayweather securing a unanimous decision victory, retaining his WBC and WBA welterweight titles. This highly anticipated bout left fans wanting more, especially after Mayweather retired undefeated at 50-0.
But here's where it gets controversial. While Mayweather has been inactive in professional boxing since 2015, Pacquiao continued his career until 2021, even challenging for the WBA welterweight title that year. Despite a recent hiatus, Pacquiao returned in 2025, leaving many wondering if he still has what it takes to compete at the highest level.
Toney's Take:
James Toney, a pound-for-pound great, doubts Mayweather's ability to replicate his past success. In an interview with ESNEWS, Toney boldly predicted a Pacquiao victory, stating, "Manny Pacquiao [wins]. He still has the movement, and I haven't seen Floyd in like 10 years." Toney's skepticism is fueled by Mayweather's prolonged absence from the professional boxing scene.
And this is the part most people miss—Mayweather's last professional fight was indeed over a decade ago, against a Pacquiao who was already considered past his prime. This detail adds an intriguing layer to Toney's prediction.
So, will Mayweather answer the call for a rematch? And if he does, can he overcome the odds and silence the doubters? The boxing community eagerly awaits the next chapter of this ongoing saga. What do you think? Is Mayweather's potential return a recipe for success or a step towards disappointment?
